Google is about to make a big change and it's gonna suuuuuuckSF Gate LogoHearst Newspapers LogoSkip to main contentCA MINI CROSSWORDHomeClassifiedsStandards & PracticesAdvertise With UsPrivacy NoticeTerms of UseAd ChoicesYour Privacy ChoicesAbout SFGATECareersContact SFGATENewslettersNewsBay AreaCalifornia WildfiresEducationNorth CoastPoliticsWeatherSports49ersGiantsA'sWarriorsBay AreaSF HistoryTravelCalifornia ParksCentral CoastHawaiiMonterey-CarmelTahoeWine CountryFood + DrinkCultureTechLos AngelesCaliforniaNational ParksReal EstateNew Homes(Virtual) Open HomesLuxuryRentalsPlace a Real Estate AdNeighborhood GuidesHome & GardenMoversObitsObituariesPlace an ObituaryBest OfShoppingPuzzlesSponsor ContentStoryStudioPaid Press ReleasesSenior LivingSponsor Content: BusinessSF Gate LogoCA MINI CROSSWORDTRENDING35m agoSorry NYC, California dominates top of America's best pizza ranking35m agoTechnologyGoogle hates youSFGATE columnist Drew Magary weighs in on the dire consequences of Google's AI pivotFILE: Alphabet Inc. and Google CEO Sundar Pichai speaks during the inauguration of a Google Artificial Intelligence hub in Paris on Feb. 15, 2024. AFP via Getty ImagesBy Drew Magary, ColumnistMay 28, 2026If you’re in my line of work, you know the phrase “search engine optimization” intimately. It haunts your dreams. It occupies space in every boring-ass PowerPoint presentation you’ve ever had to sit through. It might even be standing outside your bedroom window right now, blinking S-E-O in blinding, neon pink letters. SEO has quietly lorded over every internet writer’s work for decades now, forcing professionals like me to tailor our headlines, not to mention our very ideas, to its mysterious whims. If you want people to read your work, and I do, you must pay tribute to the SEO gods if you want that writing to be easily discovered. And you must kneel before one SEO god in particular: Google. Google has ruled the search engine market for the entirety of this century, which is why every media outlet I’ve ever worked at, this one included, has dedicated nearly endless amounts of both personnel and tech to make sure that when you, the reader, search for articles on why Meta’s new sunglasses make you look like a complete tool, by God that’s exactly what you get.FILE: A man walks past Google signage.AFP via Getty ImagesBut, while slaving away at perfecting their search engine optimization infrastructure, none of those outlets ever seriously asked themselves the question, what if there comes a day when the search engine optimizes for itself, and only itself?AdvertisementArticle continues below this adThat day has arrived. You and I know that the quality of Google’s search results has been lacking for years now. But last week, the company announced plans to essentially kill off its search results entirely, addressing all of your queries with its Gemini AI agent instead. Look at this horrible s—t. Look at it!Someone get me a cup of lye to soak my eyeballs in.Google was already attempting to steer users toward stolen content by auto-populating the top of every search with an artificial intelligence overview, followed by sponsored links and sometimes a bunch of other unwanted crap. If you want purely web-based search results from Google, you now have to hunt around for the “Web” filter in one of Google’s submenus. Or you have to manually input code into your search so that the AI demon isn’t the first thing you see. And that’s if you actually care about what you’re searching for. Many people don’t; they’ll get a top-line answer from AI and deem it not worth the trouble to click or scroll any further.AdvertisementArticle continues below this adThis is why, when Google’s algorithm de-prioritized external links, it killed off traffic to all publishing sites, this one included, by about a quarter or more virtually overnight. Sites like SFGATE need traffic to survive, and writers like me need those sites to stay alive if we hope to remain gainfully employed by them. Now Google, which is set as the default search engine in nearly every piece of tech you consume, is poised to cut off their oxygen supply altogether. So if you’ve recently asked yourself, “How can they kill journalism even deader?” — this is how.And this is why Google needs to be seized by the government and broken into a trillion little pieces.FILE: Google Co-founder and President of Products Larry Page, left, and Co-founder and President of Technology Sergey Brin appear at Google’s campus headquarters in Mountain View, Calif. Kim Kulish/Corbis via Getty ImagesThis isn’t just a me problem. You don’t have to be a writer to have your livelihood be dependent upon Google search results. Small-business owners need Google to reach potential new customers. Students, many of them working on school-issued Chromebooks made by Google, need it to research term papers and study for final exams. In its earliest form, Google dot-com was the perfect utility for all of these people and millions more. Hop in the Wayback Machine with me back to the halcyon days of 1998, when the search engine was a grad student project and not a global behemoth, now branded as Alphabet, with a market cap in the trillions of dollars. You entered your search into a little text box, and HEY PRESTO! You were given an initial list of 10 useful links, delivered with zero clutter. Early Google didn’t even have ads; it was so clean and pure.AdvertisementArticle continues below this adI cannot begin to tell you what a revelation this was to those of us surfing the neonatal internet, when our search options were limited to the motley crew of Lycos, Yahoo, Infoseek and Ask Jeeves. Jeeves knew nothing. Google Search knew what you wanted, and it gave it to you quickly, without any fuss. It was the best product in its category by far, to the point of becoming a necessary digital utility for nearly everyone on Earth. Google Search made your life, and mine, better.Demis Hassabis, the CEO of Google DeepMind, speaks at the 2026 Google I/O technology developer conference in Mountain View, Calif., on May 19, 2026.Karl Mondon/AFP/Getty ImagesBy contrast, Google’s 2026 pivot to being a nearly AI-exclusive product will still undoubtedly make your life worse. Instead of giving you precisely what you want, a Google search in 2026 is more likely to give you only what you don’t want. Want to know the definition of a word? Well, you’re gonna have to consult a physical dictionary if you hope to get a correct one. Need to know more about the Civil War? Well tough titty for you, because Gemini will hide any link to any historian’s deeply researched account and offer you a slapdash CliffsNotes version of the war instead. Google dot-com is less of a utility now than it is a roach motel: Enter something into its prompt, and suddenly you find yourself trapped inside a dungeon with no way out.The Bay Area's best free newsletter.Stay informed, and entertained.EmailSign UpYour websiteBy signing up, you agree to our Terms Of Use and acknowledge that your information will be used as described in our Privacy Policy.Social media sites like Facebook and X have long had a nasty habit of throttling links to keep you on their respective sites rather than click away from them. Google, which ditched its founding “Don’t be evil” ethos ages ago, is now doing likewise. Its latest search prototype will wall you off from other people’s writing, their products, their very ideas. The underlying hope, one imagines, is that you’ll become more reliant on machines instead of real people for your informational needs. Pretty much every other AI slop factory has a similar operating mindset, which makes all of them, collectively, an active threat to human civilization. Given Google Search’s ubiquity, its inescapability, it now stands as perhaps the greatest threat of the lot. I don’t know about you, but I’m getting really tired of all these existential threats. I was just trying to find a decent coq au vin recipe.AdvertisementArticle continues below this adFILE: Daniel Linver of San Francisco, second from left, and James Rucker, the executive director of Color of Change, which is part of a coalition called Save the Internet, carry boxes of petitions to Google’s headquarters in Mountain View, Calif., on Aug. 13, 2010.S.F Chronicle/Getty ImagesThis is a crisis born not only out of corporate greed but a collective naivete on the user side of things. I never expected Google Search to cease searching, and neither did my overlords at Hearst. I naively assumed that Google, for all of its amorality, still found tremendous financial value in the sharing of information, of using the internet’s unfathomable power to connect people with one another, and with one another’s work in turn. I didn’t expect it to become so rapacious, not to mention cynical, and that it would gleefully lead the tech sector’s charge to render human ideas, human beings, a depreciated asset. In that context, I can only see Google as an entity that hates me. And you, too. Again, I am exhausted.There is some faint hope. Internet users, myself included, are switching to purer search tools like DuckDuckGo as their default search options. And there are initial signs that the AI scam — and it is very much a scam — is losing traction with some of its implementers. So maybe you and I can look forward to a future where humane products experience a market renaissance and where the information economy isn’t ruled by a bunch of algorithms that don’t even know how to spell the word “cat.” That would be a nice world to live in. I just wish it wasn’t so hard to search for a way to get there.More Drew Magary— There's a word for the Mike Vrabels of the world, and it's 'loser'— I asked Jon Hamm if he's ever stolen from his friends— The ticket prices are too damn high— F—k Kash Patel and his $tupid shoesRead more Drew Magary on SFGATE here or sign up for his newsletter and never miss a story.May 28, 2026Drew MagaryColumnistDrew Magary is a columnist for SFGATE and a co-founder of Defector. His new book, "The Night the Lights Went Out," is available right now.CA Mini Crossword857 people are playing right now.2,282 players solved today. Can you?221 people finished in under a minute.We created a crossword puzzle just for Californians.857 people are playing right now.Play NowMost Popular1.Enormous flag draped over Hoover Dam as Lake Mead endures severe drought2.The SF tech worker whose unhinged order broke In-N-Out forever3.The Bay Area beach with a world-famous Taco Bell has a huge poop problem4.Highly contagious stomach bug surges in Northern California5.Google is about to make a big change and it's gonna suuuuuuckSHOPPINGCalpak’s travel bag sale takes 20% off luggage and backpacksCalpak’s Memorial Day sale offers 20% off luggage, carry-ons, duffel bags, backpacks, packing cubes, and travel accessories for a limited time.July drops smart carry-on with built-in trackingJuly’s Capsule Carry-On Pro features built-in tracking, quick-access storage, silent wheels, and a sleek hard-shell design.Petzl’s Tikka camping headlamp is nearly half off at REIPetzl’s Tikka Headlamp is $19.73 ($15 off) at REI. The 350 lumen lamp can shine a beam up to 70 meters, last up to 100 hours per charge, and has an IPX4 durability rating. Everyday Dose mixes coffee, mushrooms, and collagen in one drinkEveryday Dose Coffee+ combines coffee extract, Lion’s Mane mushrooms, collagen peptides, and L-Theanine in a blend designed for smoother energy and focus.SF Gate LogoDon't let Google decide who you trust.Make SFGATE a preferred source so your search results prioritize writing by actual people, not AI.Add Preferred SourceBest OfBest OfBest of Bay Area revealed this JuneThe big reveal is almost here. See the Best of Bay Area 2026 winners in June.Best OfWhy homeowners use USA Bath for bathroom upgradesIf your bathroom feels outdated, USA Bath specializes in remodels. Learn about tub-to-shower conversions, walk-in tub options and more.Best OfThese San Mateo plumbers should be in your favoritesThe best plumbing pros for your piping woes.Best OfDispensaries on the Peninsula for canna-fans of all kindsYour favorite cannabis products available close to home.Best OfStep into the Chico cannabis community at the area’s dispensariesCheck out Chico weed stores for a variety of cannabis products.Let's PlayCross|wordPile-Up PokerTypeshiftReally Bad ChessFlipartSpellTowerReturn To Top SF Gate LogoAboutOur CompanyCareersOur Use of AIEthics PolicyContactNewsroom ContactsCopyright and ReprintsServicesAdvertise with usClassifiedsRecruitmentQuick LinksReal Estate ListingsCarsJobsWeatherObituariesNewslettersAboutOur CompanyCareersOur Use of AIEthics PolicyContactNewsroom ContactsCopyright and ReprintsServicesAdvertise with usClassifiedsRecruitmentQuick LinksReal Estate ListingsCarsJobsWeatherObituariesNewslettersHearst Newspapers Logo© 2026 Hearst Communications, Inc.Terms of UsePrivacy NoticeCA Notice at CollectionYour CA Privacy Rights (Shine the Light)DAA Industry Opt OutYour Privacy Choices (Opt Out of Sale/Targeted Ads)

The author, Drew Magary, reflects on the pervasive nature of search engine optimization and Google’s recent strategic shift toward an AI-exclusive search model, arguing that this change poses a significant threat to the publishing industry and the broader information ecosystem. Magary posits that for decades, the entire structure of internet writing has been dictated by SEO, forcing content creators to tailor their work to satisfy the search engine, which he identifies as Google. He contends that this dynamic has led media outlets to dedicate substantial resources to SEO management, ensuring their content is discoverable, rather than critically assessing the inherent priorities of the content delivery system.

Magary observes that the previous iteration of Google Search functioned as a powerful utility, providing users with initially useful, uncluttered results. He contrasts this past state with the present, noting that Google’s move to prioritize its Gemini AI agent is perceived as a systemic dismantling of the system intended to connect people with information and work. This pivot is criticized because it actively de-prioritizes external links, which has resulted in a significant reduction in traffic to publishing sites, including media outlets like SFGATE, thereby jeopardizing the financial viability of journalism.

The author suggests that this transition is not merely a technical update but a profound philosophical shift driven by corporate objectives. He expresses concern that making search results increasingly dependent on AI will lead to a state where the search engine optimizes solely for itself, potentially trapping users in an informational "dungeon" where AI-generated, superficial answers displace deeply researched human content. This outcome fosters reliance on machines rather than human expertise for informational needs, which Magary views as an existential threat to human civilization, particularly as other AI systems operate with similar, potentially malicious, mindsets.

The author attributes this crisis to a combination of corporate greed and user naivete regarding the capabilities and intentions of the technology. He laments the realization that Google, having abandoned its founding principles, has become rapacious, aiming to render human ideas and beings depreciated assets. While acknowledging the existential dread associated with these algorithmic changes, Magary finds faint hope in the emergent trend of users seeking alternatives, such as DuckDuckGo, and nascent skepticism regarding the viability of the current AI-driven information delivery models. He concludes by expressing a desire for a future where information products experience a market renaissance and are governed by principles that value human content and genuine utility rather than purely algorithmic control.