Is the Ferrari Luce’s Design Really That Bad? 3 Italian Auto Experts Weigh In | WIREDSkip to main contentMenuSECURITYPOLITICSTHE BIG STORYBUSINESSSCIENCECULTUREREVIEWSMenuAccountAccountNewslettersBest Computer SpeakersOutdoor Security CamerasBest Smart RingsRouters vs. ModemsBest Power BanksDeals DeliveredSecurityPoliticsThe Big StoryBusinessScienceCultureReviewsChevronMoreExpandThe Big InterviewMagazineEventsWIRED InsiderWIRED ConsultingNewslettersPodcastsVideoLivestreamsMerchSearchSearchLucia TedescoGearMay 30, 2026 5:00 AMIs the Ferrari Luce’s Design Really That Bad? 3 Italian Auto Experts Weigh InThe first electric Ferrari is already this year’s most divisive car. We asked three Italian auto industry professionals to explain where the EV’s design makes sense, and where it doesn’t add up.Courtesy of FerrariCommentLoaderSave StorySave this storyCommentLoaderSave StorySave this storyThe Ferrari Luce, the first electric vehicle in the brand’s history, has generated heated discussion online, as comments and opinions about the design continue to bounce around the web.The Luce, an electric sedan with a $650,000 price tag that Ferrari presented with pomp and circumstance at the Quirinale in Rome on Monday, has paid dearly for its coming out from behind the curtain. Since Monday, the automaker has been suffering an avalanche of complaints and skepticism about the Luce. It’s not just the price—which is high even for a Ferrari—but what the car represents and how it fits into the brand’s long and storied legacy. The day after the EV’s debut, Ferrari stock dipped 8 percent.Luca Cordero di Montezemolo, Ferrari’s former chairman, said, “We risk the destruction of a myth.” Carlo Calenda, an Italian senator and the country’s former economic minister, called the release an “aesthetic and technological insult,” and took the opportunity to attack John Elkann—the leader of the Agnelli family, which owns a controlling stake in Ferrari—and his management of the family's assets. Closing the circle was Matteo Salvini, who as Italy’s minister of transport felt compelled to intervene. His negative assessment, accompanied by an invocation of Enzo Ferrari, demonstrates that anything can be said about the Luce.Beyond anything one might think, the Luce is a radically different car from its predecessors. It weighs roughly a ton more than a hybrid, uses four electric motors (one per wheel), and is built to seat five people. Its ability to sprint from zero to 100 kilometers per hour in 2.5 seconds is impressive; the instantaneous acceleration even required Ferrari to consult with NASA in order to keep the sensations of such an acceleration from being physically unpleasant. The “engine note” inside the car uses electronically treated mechanical sounds.“It’s clear that this is a product designed not by a car designer but by a product designer.”Automotive designer Maurizio CorbiWe discussed the disruptive and divisive Luce with Maurizio Corbi, a car designer with more than 30 years of experience. Corbi, who trained at the industrial design firm Bertone and later at the car designer Pininfarina, explains why the Ferrari Luce has triggered such polarized reactions, both among insiders and the general public.“I suspect it's a powerful marketing ploy,” Corbi says. “They literally threw a boulder in a pond, and that's all people are talking about. I can't recall anything similar.”“The world of cars, and design in particular, follows a fine line. It's constantly evolving, but there's always a need for a culture rooted in time. Ferrari, when it comes to road cars, means Pininfarina. The brand's greatest masterpieces bear that signature. [Ferrari’s] current design director, Flavio Manzoni, has been able to innovate while still keeping a close eye on that tradition. I fear that he too has been affected by this project, because he is too detached from the path Ferrari has taken in recent years.”As for the formal criticisms of the Luce’s flat surfaces and lack of emotion, Corbi says, “It's clear that this is a product designed not by a car designer but by a product designer.”Ferrari enlisted Marc Newson and ex-Apple designer Jony Ive from the agency LoveFrom to work on the interior and exterior of the Luce. “This gentleman came from Apple and is used to designing objects of that type. The car is something else, it's not industrial design,” Corbi says. “A good industrial designer isn't capable of designing a car; it's another profession.”“The involvement of Jony Ive and Marc Newson almost seems like a choice of boundless arrogance, as if to say, let's not care about what our customers love and just sell this to them. The stock price has lost 8 percent. I have American friends, Ferrari owners who are members of the Ferrari Club of America, people in love with the brand, who are shocked. As is [former Ferrari chairman] Montezemolo, who yesterday publicly expressed his disappointment.”Corbi says the design of the car lacks innovation. “From the standpoint of volume, Ferrari has designed a family soap bar: It’s the negation of everything that is a Ferrari. Then there are those little wheels. We car designers had the desire to make ever larger wheels, ever sharper, more aerodynamic shapes. Here we have returned to our grandfather's car, without any stylistic features that hark back to the Ferrari tradition.”On whether this change in visual language heralds a new direction for the entire Ferrari lineup, Corbi does not rule it out. “Since the language is so different, they probably intend to create a line of electric cars with their own independent philosophy.”“People were already worried when they previewed the interiors,” Corbi says. “They aren't exactly Ferrari-like in style, even if they appreciated the innovation, attention to detail, and materials. It's also true that those who buy a car look at the exterior first. And those who buy a Ferrari are loyal customers, financially sound, who move from one model to another while remaining loyal to the brand.”Corbi concedes that his judgment is probably influenced by a more traditional culture. “But those who buy a Ferrari aren't 20-year-olds,” he says. “They're mature people with significant financial resources. That's their target; it's pointless to pretend that a customer's expectations can change just because there's a prancing horse on the front. If I want a Ferrari, it has to meet certain precise requirements. It's an iconic object, and there's little to discuss.”He also questions the very idea of ​​an electric Ferrari. “A Ferrari is a combustion engine with a body. If you remove the engine, you're left with an empty container. Just look at Porsche's experience, which has bet everything on electric and is finding itself in serious difficulty.”“The exterior is well designed. Clean, proportioned, refined. But it’s not a Ferrari.”Automotive designer Alessandro CipolliAlessandro Cipolli is a car designer with more than 20 years of experience in the automotive industry who specializes in interior design, exterior design, and 3D modeling. He suggested another point of view, namely that the sore point is not so much about execution but about feeling.“It was right and inevitable that Ferrari would enter the electric world,” Cipolli says. “The technology is simply a masterpiece, it shows that they are ahead of everyone else.”The design situation, Cipolli says, is more complicated. “The exterior is well designed. Clean, proportioned, refined. But it's not a Ferrari. It lacks that tension, that strength, that character that strikes you before you even have time to analyze. The interior is even more eloquent. The collaboration with Jony Ive is evident: high-quality execution, meticulous detailing, precise interfaces. But it's an interior that speaks Apple, not Ferrari. Take away the logo and you don't know where you are.”Cipolli says the Luce lacks emotional appeal. “The car is very well designed. The details have been taken care of, the surfaces are flawless, the materials chosen are of high quality, the division of the passenger compartment from the bodywork is very beautiful. But here we go beyond the execution to talk about emotions. Beyond the function, a car designer takes emotions into account. Transferring emotions into a car is not easy, but in this case it was not taken into account. This car does not excite.”“Making a car, like making any object, is complex work. It’s a philosophical endeavor that then emerges from its forms.”Designer Carlo GainoFinally we spoke to Carlo Gaino, who had a completely different opinion. Gaino is a designer, the founder of Synthesis design, and a professor at the Polytechnic University of Turin. He bluntly dismantles the aesthetic choices of the new Ferrari.“It’s a classic example of what happens when you call on profoundly ignorant people—in the sense that they ignore the history of the automobile—to design one of the most iconic brands in existence.” he says. “People who never had the expertise to do that have put their hands on Ferrari. If you want to destroy a brand, as Montezemolo rightly said, you do that.”“We are in a historical moment in which culture is under attack,” Gaino says. “Those who know how to do a job, those with real skills, are systematically sidelined. I taught for a few decades between the Polytechnic University of Turin and IUAV University of Venice, and in recent years, students were using AI routinely. Tesla is the product of artificial intelligence, and it's obvious from a mile away. Putting the world of design in the hands of those tools is a huge mistake. Making a car, like making any object, is complex work. It’s a philosophical endeavor that then emerges from its forms.”Regarding the external aspects of the car and the visual choices made by the Luce’s designers, Gaino says: “Those formal solutions were already circulating in the ’80s and ’90s, especially in Japanese design. What you see on the Luce are the choices of beginners, not those who have studied the history.”“Last Friday in Modena I saw the premiere of a documentary on Alejandro de Tomaso,” Gaino says. De Tomaso was a Formula One racer and businessman who started his own sports car company, De Tomaso Automobili. “That man had the ability to be innovative without seeking consensus, without wanting to be praised. Working with him wasn't easy, but he had a vision. This country grew in the ’50s and ’60s thanks to figures like Olivetti [the Italian personal technology manufacturer]. There are still those who work like this, those who believe that design can improve people's lives. But it has almost become out of fashion.”This story was originally published by WIRED Italia and has been translated from Italian.CommentsBack to topTriangleYou Might Also LikeHow to find us: Add WIRED.com to your preferred sources in GoogleHow the Canvas hack threatened thousands of schoolsBig Story: I've covered robots for years—this one is eerily lifelikeOrbs, saucers, and flashes on the moon—here’s what’s in the UFO filesTake our survey: What does “home” mean to you?Lucia Tedesco is a journalist, film critic, and feminist. She writes about culture, entertainment, and technology. ... Read MoreTopicscarsElectric Vehiclesautomobilesferraridesigncar designRead MoreThe 19 Most Exciting Cars at the Beijing Auto Show 2026The cars that debuted at the Beijing Auto Show demonstrate that the Chinese market is now at the forefront of electrification and intelligence. These are the 19 most intriguing models we saw.Daisuke TakimotoTesla’s Latest Recall? Wheels May Fall Off CybertrucksIn what is the 11th Cybertruck recall, certain models of Elon Musk’s embattled pickup could experience a sudden, unexpected wheel separation, thanks to the wrong grease and loose nuts.Jeremy WhiteAll Vehicles Sold in the EU Must Be Able to Hook Up to a BreathalyzerThe measure is part of a European Union–led strategy to eliminate all drunk-driving-related deaths and injuries by 2050.Fernanda GonzálezTesla Reveals New Details About Robotaxi Crashes—and the Humans InvolvedRemote operators (slowly) drove the automaker’s autonomous vehicles into a metal fence and a construction barricade, Tesla says.Aarian MarshallGantri’s 3D-Printed Lamps Are Going WirelessIn a partnership with design firm Ammunition, the lamp company is taking its lights wireless.Boone AshworthAI Promised the Audemars Piguet x Swatch Wristwatch. China Will Deliver ItWatch fans spent a week falling in love with colorful Royal Oak wristwatches that didn’t exist—then the real thing arrived. Now, fantasy is becoming a manufacturing opportunity.Jeremy WhiteThe Catastrophic Swatch x Audemars Piguet Launch Was Entirely Predictable and Utterly AvoidableSo why didn’t Swatch do anything to avoid it?Jeremy WhiteThis Is the Real Swatch x Audemars Piguet Royal Pop CollaborationWith Instagram awash with inaccurate AI-generated concepts for its Royal Pop collab, Swatch was forced to reveal the genuine article.Jeremy WhiteThe Problem With Nike’s World Cup Uniforms Made of TrashThe activewear giant has used chemical recycling to make jersey for 16 teams competing in the tournament. But the technique is unlikely to help solve fashion’s waste issue.Joseph WintersThe Best Aluminum Carry-Ons Make You Look Like a Jet-Setting DJAll-metal carry-ons give you that business class, turn-left-on-a-plane look. But are they worth the cost of your entire vacation?Chris HaslamA Fundamental Principle of Aeronautical Engineering Has Been OverturnedIt’s long been accepted that the smoother the surface, the lower the aerodynamic drag. That turns out not always to be the case.Ritsuko KawaiThe Best Webcams for Looking Bushy-Tailed on ZoomI tested all the major webcams across the price spectrum in attempts to find the very best. Here's what I learned.Luke LarsenWired CouponsSquarespace Promo Code10% Off Exclusive Squarespace Promo Code 2026Home Depot Promo CodeMemorial Day Appliance Deals + Up to an Extra $1000 Off + Free Delivery on appliance purchases $998+LG Promo CodeLG Promo Code: 20% Off Your First OrderDell Coupon CodeDell Promo Code 20% OffSamsung Promo Code30% Samsung Coupon - Offer Program 2026Doordash Promo CodeDoordash Coupon $20 OffWIRED is obsessed with what comes next. Through rigorous investigations and game-changing reporting, we tell stories that don’t just reflect the moment—they help create it. When you look back in 10, 20, even 50 years, WIRED will be the publication that led the story of the present, mapped the people, products, and ideas defining it, and explained how those forces forged the future. WIRED: For Future Reference.More From WIREDSubscribeNewslettersLivestreamsTravelFAQWIRED StaffWIRED EducationEditorial StandardsArchiveRSSSite MapAccessibility HelpReviews and GuidesReviewsBuying GuidesStreaming GuidesWearablesCouponsGift GuidesAdvertiseContact UsManage AccountJobsPress CenterCondé Nast StoreUser AgreementPrivacy PolicyYour California Privacy Rights© 2026 Condé Nast. All rights reserved. WIRED may earn a portion of sales from products that are purchased through our site as part of our Affiliate Partnerships with retailers. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Condé Nast. Ad ChoicesSelect international siteUnited StatesLargeChevronItaliaJapónCzech Republic & SlovakiaFacebookXPinterestYouTubeInstagramTiktok

The introduction of the Ferrari Luce, the brand's first electric vehicle, immediately generated significant public and industry controversy regarding its design. The vehicle, priced at $650,000, provoked strong reactions concerning its entry into electric technology and its perceived deviation from Ferrari's established legacy. This public skepticism was reflected in negative responses from Italian figures, including Luca Cordero di Montezemolo, who expressed concern about the potential destruction of a brand myth, and Carlo Calenda, who labeled the release an aesthetic and technological insult.

Technically, the Luce is a radical departure from previous models, featuring a weight increase compared to hybrid versions, four electric motors (one per wheel), and seating for five passengers. Its performance, including an impressive acceleration time of 2.5 seconds to 100 kilometers per hour, necessitated consultation with NASA to ensure the experience was not physically unpleasant, with the interior soundscape utilizing electronically treated mechanical sounds.

Automotive designer Maurizio Corbi offered an analysis of the controversy, suggesting the design stemmed more from a product designer's perspective than a car designer’s. Corbi posited that the reaction might be a marketing ploy, noting that the automotive world requires a cultural grounding in time, where Ferrari’s masterpieces have always adhered to the Pininfarina signature. He criticized the aesthetic choices, observing that the design lacked necessary stylistic features harkening back to Ferrari tradition, suggesting that the vehicle represented the negation of everything that defines the brand from a volume standpoint. Corbi also noted the involvement of designers like Jony Ive and Marc Newson, questioning whether this collaboration represented boundless arrogance rather than customer focus.

Alessandro Cipolli focused his critique on the distinction between execution and emotion. While acknowledging that the exterior design is well-executed—clean, proportioned, and refined—Cipolli argued that it fundamentally fails to embody the essence of Ferrari. He found that the interior design, in collaboration with Jony Ive, while meticulously detailed, communicated more about Apple than about Ferrari, essentially lacking the emotional appeal necessary to excite the observer.

Carlo Gaino provided a more philosophical dismantling of the aesthetic decisions. Gaino asserted that the controversy arose from ignoring the history of the automobile in favor of superficial design choices. He contended that putting design in the hands of those lacking expertise is a mistake, emphasizing that creating a car is a complex philosophical endeavor emergent from form. Gaino further suggested that the external solutions seen in the Luce were already circulating in prior decades, particularly in Japanese design, implying the choices reflected the errors of beginners rather than historical mastery. He reflected on the decline of visionary figures who sought innovation without consensus, lamenting that design has almost become out of fashion.

Ultimately, the discussion highlighted a tension between technological advancement and brand heritage, with observers debating whether the shift to electric design and modern aesthetic principles successfully translates the historical emotional resonance associated with the Ferrari name into the physical form of the new vehicle.